The P1.1-billion submarine cable project of the Davao del Norte Electric Cooperative (Daneco) to energize Samal Island has not been approved by the Energy Regulatory Commission (ERC). In fact, no application for the project has been filed with ERC yet.
This was bared by consumer watchdog People’s Oversight Watchdog for Energy Reforms (POWER) through its national coordinator Jaydar Medrozo.
“It is unfortunate that consumers and political leaders have been deceived to believe that such a huge project is on its way to deliver ample and reliable power to the people of Samal,” Medrozo said.
“In reality, this project has not been filed and reviewed by regulators. The ERC has been a staunch protector of consumers against energy price hikes and corruption in the energy industry. We earnestly believe the ERC, under the leadership of Chair (Agnes) Devanadera, will never approve a project of this magnitude, given the franchise size and financial condition of Daneco.”
As the regulator in the power industry, the ERC is mandated to review expenses and approve major projects of distribution utilities and electric cooperatives in order to protect the welfare of the consumers from over-charging and ensure electricity charges are fair.
POWER wrote a letter to the ERC inquiring about the submarine cable project when Daneco officials touted the completion of the15-kilometer submarine cable project that is supposed to connect Samal Island with the municipality of Pantukan in Davao de Oro.
In its July 28 reply, the ERC — through chair Devanadera — said the commission has not yet received an application nor approved such a project.
“(T)he 14-kilometer submarine cable capital expenditure project of DANECO, the Commission has yet to receive nor approve any CAPEX application relating to this project. Thus, the Commission has no information about the details of this project of DANECO,” the letter read.
The same ERC letter said it approved in 2011 a P101.7-million project of Daneco for “Uprating the Capacity of an Existing Submarine Cable from 15 kV to 69 kV Capacity.” The existing submarine cable, measuring around 1 kilometer, connects Samal and Davao City.
A check on the facility showed the submarine cable has not been upgraded. Instead, Daneco has signed contracts with more expensive diesel-fired generation sets to be put up in Samal to help the island with its power supply.
Despite this multi-million upgrading project, Daneco General manager Mario Angelo Sotto said in a June 30 interview with government-owned Philippine News Agency (PNA) that the Davao submarine cable is “impractical.”
He insisted that the longer, more expensive Pantukan line is best for Samal.
“They will no longer experience brownouts and we are happy to tell them that we will not add any charges when this submarine cable will be installed. They will still pay the same amount,” Sotto assured in a September 2019 interview, also with PNA.
He said the submarine cable is set for completion in March 2020.
Meanwhile, Engr. Emmanuel Galarse, board chairman of Daneco and who is also general manager for Agusan del Sur Electric Cooperative, told PNA that the cable which was ordered in Germany was expected to arrive in June or July 2020.
Medrozo of POWER said without an approval from ERC, Daneco cannot pass on the recovery of the investment to its consumers.
“The people of Samal and the rest of Davao del Norte and Davao de Oro will suffer a huge increase in power rates if this project pushes through. Daneco already has one of the most expensive power in the Philippines, burdening the consumers with more charges will definitely cripple the economy and destroy household budgets,” Medrozo said.
“This project must be looked into by the local government and the consumers. We call on the ERC, Ombudsman, and even Congress to look into. Who approved this project inside Daneco? Why did this project pass the scrutiny of the NEA? Where will they get the money? Is this technically and financially sound given the situation of Daneco?” Medrozo said.
Cebu-based POWER has been active in representing consumer interests in Visayas-Mindanao. It has led the fight for reduction in power rates in Cebu, Surigao, Cagayan de Oro, and even in Meralco through its network of like-minded organizations.





